Squashing the Dread of Delivering Difficult Feedback: A Guide for Managers

“Be not afraid of greatness,” the immortal words of Shakespeare echo in our minds. Now it’s time to apply this wisdom to one of the toughest parts of leadership: giving tough feedback.
Squashing the Dread of Delivering Difficult Feedback: A Guide for Managers
Two business people discussing and talking in the office.

As managers, we are often saddled with the responsibility of ensuring our teams perform optimally. Sometimes, this requires us to deliver hard-hitting feedback. It’s not an easy task and for good reason. The fear of being labeled the “bad guy,” causing emotional distress, or triggering an adverse reaction can be daunting. But remember, not giving feedback can be far more damaging than giving it. Let’s navigate this journey to fearless feedback together.

The Real Cost of Avoiding Feedback

Neglecting to provide critical feedback can cause more harm than good. It’s like ignoring a leak in a boat because you’re afraid of making a noise to fix it; ultimately, the boat is going to sink.

In business terms, this could lead to declining performance, decreasing team morale, and stunting individual growth.

Overcoming the fear of feedback is not just about managing efficiently; it’s about fostering an environment of continual improvement and shared growth.

Takeaway: Ignoring the issue doesn’t solve it. Feedback is a crucial tool in improving team performance and morale.

Embracing Constructive Criticism

Changing our mindset around feedback is the first step. Start seeing it as a tool for growth, not a mechanism for pointing out flaws. Adopting this perspective transforms the experience into a positive one, for you and the employee.

Takeaway: Change your perspective. Feedback is a growth mechanism.

The Art of Delivering Tough Feedback

Tough feedback doesn’t have to be a tough conversation. Here’s a four-step guide to make it less daunting.

  1. Prepare: Take time to gather your thoughts and identify specific areas for improvement. Avoid personal criticisms and focus on behaviors and performance.
  2. Empathize: Understand their viewpoint and anticipate their reactions. This will help in making the conversation a two-way street, rather than a one-way critique.
  3. Communicate:Keep it straightforward and factual. Provide clear examples to highlight your points. It’s not just about pointing out the problem, but also suggesting a path to improvement.
  4. Listen: Encourage them to share their feelings and thoughts. This fosters a sense of trust and respect, making the feedback more palatable.

As the renowned management thinker Peter Drucker said, “The most important thing in communication is to hear what isn’t being said.” Listen not only to what they’re saying but also to what they’re not.

Takeaway: Proper preparation, empathy, clear communication, and attentive listening can make tough feedback more digestible.

Final Thoughts

Fear of giving tough feedback is common, but it’s not insurmountable. Remember, the aim of feedback is improvement, not criticism. By changing our perspective and adopting a structured approach, we can make the process less painful and more productive.

In the words of Bill Gates, “We all need people who will give us feedback. That’s how we improve.” So let’s shed the fear and pave the way for improvement.

On path.mba, we aim to guide managers through the toughest aspects of their roles, offering practical advice drawn from extensive research and real-life experience. If you’re looking to further develop your managerial skills, keep an eye out for our upcoming articles and resources.

Join the conversation on this topic, share your experiences and thoughts. How do you approach giving feedback? Do you have any tried-and-tested strategies? Let’s learn and grow together.

Related Posts
A Manager's Blueprint for Discovery-Driven Growth in Business
Leer más

A Manager’s Blueprint for Discovery-Driven Growth in Business

Explore the concept of discovery-driven growth, a strategy proposed by Columbia Business School Professor Rita McGrath. This approach flips traditional business planning on its head, advocating for learning and adaptability over rigid expectations and goals. Dive into its principles and learn how to successfully incorporate it into your business to navigate uncertainties and seize growth opportunities.